While Emmett was in London, he fell in love with one of his clients, Nora. As a result, rumors of misconduct arose across Caplan & Gold's staff. He was later promoted to managing partner of Caplan & Gold, Emmett made it his mission to make sure that the firm wouldn't receive any further setbacks such as the one from Jorge Castillo. One of the big changes he had to make was to move to the US from London to deal with the Jorge mess. ("Your Funeral", "The Baby Was Never Dead", "Be the Martyr")
Emmett also recommended a partner position to the board for Annalise Keating. During the interview with Annalise, Emmett introduces himself and makes a comment about him thinking that she would be taller. He asks Tegan Price to show them to one of the conference rooms. Emmett informs Annalise that he is from the London branch of Caplan & Gold meaning that he doesn't know where everything is located yet. At the interview with some of the other partners, Emmett gives Annalise the talk about what he and his firm are willing to offer her. Annalise makes a comment on her salary which she mocks and tells them that she has been offered double the amount from other offers from other law firms. Annalise then asks about whether she will be able to hire her own team for the class action retrials. Emmett tells her that he will allow it and asks her to give it a few days to think about it. Annalise stops him and tells him that she doesn't think that it is a good fit for her at the firm due to how desperate they are.
A couple of days later, Annalise returned to Caplan & Gold and offered them the chance to repair their reputation by being a funder in her Legal Clinic along with the university. Willing to negotiate, he tells Annalise that she will have to compromise on some of her demands, however, Annalise refuses to negotiate any further and leaves. Not long later, he and the partners decide to call Annalise, offering her the job. He later gives Annalise her office and tells her to prove the other partners wrong as he was the only partner who believed in her. ("Your Funeral")
When asked why the Castillos would target a man like him, Emmett informs the FBI that he is running for District Attorney. Unlike past DA's (such as Todd Denver), Emmett is a man of integrity who cannot be bought. The FBI releases Emmett, and the two of them return to C&G for a celebratory drink. Emmett offers Tegan a glass of scotch, but Tegan (an established gin drinker) declines, telling Emmett not to start until she returns with her drink of choice.
While Tegan is gone, Birkhead declares herself vindicated of all accusations and publicly accuses Emmett of being a part of Nate Senior's murder. Terrified for her own safety, Tegan calls Annalise to inform her of the governor's announcement and asks if she can sleep at Annalise's house. Meanwhile, Emmett lies upstairs choking to death. ("Please Say No One Else Is Dead")
Tegan informing Annalise that Emmett is dead. ("Say Goodbye")
Emmett is convulsing on the floor when Tegan arrives with her gin. She gives him CPR, to no avail. Emmett's body was later transferred to London under the orders of the other C&G partners. ("Say Goodbye") The order was signed off on by Tegan (who was instructed to do so by her bosses), leading Nate Lahey to believe that Tegan poisoned Emmett. ("Vivian's Here").
The FBI also consider Tegan a possible murder suspect, as she was the only person present when Emmett died. Tegan is cleared of suspicion after the London medical examiner determined that Emmett's death was due to a heart attack. However, a number of people (including Tegan) continued to believe that Emmett was poisoned at the behest of Governor Birkhead.
- On July 30, 2018, it was announced that Timothy Hutton signed on as a series regular for How to Get Away with Murder's fifth season. The character's name was first revealed on set by fellow costar Amirah Vann (Tegan Price).
- Emmett is one of only two main characters in the show's run who was never tied to a murder (the other being Rebecca Sutter).
- Hutton's run makes him the actor with the least amount of appearances as a main cast member (12).
|"Your Funeral"||"Whose Blood Is That?"||"The Baby Was Never Dead"||"It's Her Kid"||"It Was the Worst Day of My Life"|
|"We Can Find Him"||"I Got Played"||"I Want to Love You Until the Day I Die"||"He Betrayed Us Both"||"Don't Go Dark on Me"|
|"Be the Martyr"||"We Know Everything"||"Where Are Your Parents?"||"Make Me the Enemy"||"Please Say No One Else Is Dead"|
Behind the ScenesEdit